Current:Home > FinancePublic Comments on Pipeline Plans May Be Slipping Through Cracks at FERC, Audit Says-LoTradeCoin
Public Comments on Pipeline Plans May Be Slipping Through Cracks at FERC, Audit Says
View Date:2024-12-23 22:50:24
The federal process for approving new natural gas pipelines is veiled from the public, does a poor job of tracking their views, and may not be considering their concerns when weighing new projects, according to a new auditor’s report.
Environmental and pipeline safety advocates say the U.S. Department of Energy’s Office of Inspector General’s findings about the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) are alarming, if not surprising.
“It’s frankly quite troubling, but at the same time, this is not news to those folks who have been impacted by proposed pipelines and those folks who try to be involved and navigate FERC’s system,” Montina Cole, a senior energy advocate with the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC).
The report found that FERC lacked a consistent process for tracking public comments on proposed pipeline projects, suggesting that all comments might not be reviewed.
“In the absence of a consistent methodology, we did not verify to what degree comments received by FERC were considered, aggregated, and reflected in the environmental documents or final orders for the certificate applications during our review,” the report concluded. “The lack of a consistent methodology could increase the risk that FERC may not address significant and impactful public comments in the environmental document or final order.”
“If people’s comments are not being reviewed at all, that is highly problematic and completely unacceptable,” Cole said. “There are high stakes here; people’s lives, their livelihoods, property and certainly the environmental on which we all depend.”
Concerns Poor Communities May Not Be Heard
The findings of the inspector general’s May 24 report mirror those of a 2017 report commissioned by NRDC. That report concluded that the Commission needed to better take into account public comments, especially from stakeholders with limited resources.
An example of how individuals with limited resources feel their concerns have not received proper consideration is currently playing out in Virginia.
On May 30, Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam’s Advisory Council on Environmental Justice called for a moratorium on new gas infrastructure in the state, including the Atlantic Coast and Mountain Valley pipelines, in part due to federal regulators’ failure to address concerns expressed by low-income communities of color living along the routes of the proposed pipelines.
Information Difficult to Find Online, Audit Says
The current inspector general’s report also found fault with accessibility of FERC records, saying it was difficult to find information through the commission’s website.
From 2006 to 2015, it said, FERC also failed to provide schedules of environmental reviews on proposed pipelines in the federal register, limiting the ability of interested parties, including other federal agencies, to submit comment.
The report noted that part of the problem stemmed from the fact that the commission had not specifically designed its website for use by the general public but rather intended it for insiders like industry, government officials and lawyers.
The deficiencies have caused many problems, said Carl Weimer, executive director of Pipeline Safety Trust, a watchdog group.
“Far too often the frustration with the FERC approval process leads to a long term distrust by the public of the pipeline companies and other government regulators that have to ensure the safe operation of these pipelines long after the FERC process is finished,” Weimer wrote in an email.
Fixing Problems Might Not Be So Simple
The report included a response from FERC Chairman Kevin McIntyre, who said the Commission would work to address the issues raised.
Doing so, however, may prove difficult.
“I hope they will improve the system, but these are still technically complicated issues that are going to be difficult for people who are not steeped in the details to participate in,” said Ari Peskoe, an expert in energy law at Harvard University. “They can try to explain things better, they can try to have a more user-friendly interface, but at the end of the day, it’s still a very technical proceeding.”
FERC is currently reviewing its pipeline permitting process, including whether the process can be improved.
“The issue is not so much the efficiency of FERC’s process, whether they can do it quickly or not, but the sufficiency,” Cole said. “‘Is the process sufficient’, and I think the answer is clearly no.”
veryGood! (7955)
Related
- Jake Paul's only loss led him to retool the team preparing him to face Mike Tyson
- German government wants companies to 'de-risk' from China, but business is reluctant
- Israeli company gets green light to make world’s first cultivated beef steaks
- Fans sue Madonna, Live Nation over New York concert starting 2 hours late
- John Robinson, successful football coach at USC and with the LA Rams, has died at 89
- Foo Fighters, Chris Stapleton will join The Rolling Stones at 2024 New Orleans Jazz Fest
- AP Decision Notes: What to expect in the Bridgeport, Connecticut, do-over mayoral primary
- Madonna sued over late concert start time
- Chiefs block last-second field goal to save unbeaten record, beat Broncos
- France police detain 13-year-old over at least 380 false bomb threats
Ranking
- 2024 'virtually certain' to be warmest year on record, scientists say
- What's Making Us Happy: A guide to your weekend viewing
- After domestic abuse ends, the effects of brain injuries can persist
- UFC's Sean Strickland made a vile anti-LGBTQ attack. ESPN's response is disgracefully weak
- Georgia House Democrats shift toward new leaders after limited election gains
- Biden forgives $5 billion more in student loan debt. Here's who qualifies and how to apply.
- Kristen Stewart Debuts Micro Bangs Alongside Her Boldest Outfit Yet
- LeVar Burton stunned to discover ancestor served with Confederacy on 'Finding Your Roots'
Recommendation
-
The Bachelorette's Desiree Hartsock Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Chris Siegfried
-
Alabama inmate asking federal appeals court to block first-ever execution by nitrogen gas
-
Pakistan seeks to de-escalate crisis with Iran after deadly airstrikes that spiked tensions
-
Louisiana lawmakers pass new congressional map with second majority-Black district
-
Surfer Bethany Hamilton Makes Masked Singer Debut After 3-Year-Old Nephew’s Tragic Death
-
American Airlines plane slides off runway at New York's Rochester Airport
-
Man arrested in series of New York City stabbings, police say
-
California Senate leader Toni Atkins announces run for governor in 2026